Stats

The reviews the critics could not agree on. Every figure states its sample size.

Most divisive reviews

Title	Scores	Mean	Spread	Highest	Lowest
Star Wars Jedi: Survivor	3	8.00	2.00	Greg Miller 5/5	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 3/5
Mafia: The Old Country	3	5.17	1.89	Roger Pokorny 6.5/10	Mike Howard 3/10
Avatar: The Way of Water	5	8.40	1.67	Tim Gettys 5/5	Nick Scarpino 3/5
Pragmata	3	6.83	1.53	Tim Gettys 8.5/10	Roger Pokorny 5.5/10
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth	5	8.00	1.41	Tim Gettys 5/5	Roger Pokorny 3/5
Life is Strange: Double Exposure	7	7.07	1.40	Roger Pokorny 9/10	Greg Miller 5.5/10
Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII - Reunion	4	5.75	1.26	Michael Higham 7/10	Roger Pokorny 2/5
Ninja Gaiden 4	3	6.67	1.26	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 8/10	Roger Pokorny 5.5/10
Hellblade II: Senua's Saga	4	7.50	1.23	Mike Howard 9/10	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 6.5/10
Elden Ring	3	9.33	1.16	Tamoor Hussain 5/5	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 4/5
Brotato: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition	8	7.75	1.13	Greg Miller 9/10	Andy Cortez 6/10
Avowed	4	8.00	1.08	Parris Lilly 9.5/10	Andy Cortez 7/10
Starfield	8	7.38	1.03	Greg Miller 9/10	Barrett Courtney 6/10
Marvel's Spider-Man 2	4	9.50	1.00	Greg Miller 5/5	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 4/5
Horizon Forbidden West	5	9.60	0.89	Greg Miller 5/5	Andy Cortez 4/5
Directive 8020	3	6.50	0.87	Madeline Stanley 7.5/10	Joey Noelle 6/10
Keeper	3	8.33	0.76	Parris Lilly 9/10	Mike Howard 7.5/10
LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight	3	7.83	0.76	Joey Noelle 8.5/10	Barrett Courtney 7/10
Ghost of Yotei	3	8.83	0.76	Roger Pokorny 9.5/10	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 8/10
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33	6	9.00	0.71	Mike Howard 10/10	Tim Gettys 8/10
Onimusha: Way of the Sword	4	7.75	0.65	Tim Gettys 8.5/10	Jordan Middler 7/10
Halo: Campaign Evolved	4	8.12	0.63	Parris Lilly 9/10	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 7.5/10
Tekken 8	3	9.67	0.58	Chris Scullion 5/5	Mitchell Saltzman 9/10
Hollow Knight Silksong	3	9.67	0.58	Barrett Courtney 10/10	Tim Gettys 9/10
Blue Prince	3	9.67	0.58	Jason Schreier 10/10	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 9/10
Borderlands	3	2.67	0.58	Nick Scarpino 3/10	Mike Howard 2/10
Sonic Frontiers	3	6.33	0.58	Mitchell Saltzman 7/10	Blessing Adeoye Jr. 3/5
Mixtape	4	9.50	0.58	Tim Gettys 10/10	Barrett Courtney 9/10
Supergirl	3	6.33	0.58	Barrett Courtney 7/10	Andy Cortez 6/10
007 First Light	7	9.14	0.56	Jordan Middler 5/5	Tim Gettys 8.5/10

Minimum 3 scores. Spread is the standard deviation across critics — the higher it is, the more they disagreed. Highest and lowest scores are shown on the scale they were spoken on.