16 Oct 2023
| Critic | Score | In their words |
|---|---|---|
| Tim Gettys | 5/5 | “Spider-Man 2 is a five out of five.” |
| Greg Miller | 5/5 | “This is a five out of five for me.” |
| Blessing Adeoye Jr. | 4/5 | “I'm going to give it a four out of five.” |
| Andy Cortez | no score | Was on the episode but didn't give a number. |
| Barrett Courtney | no score | Was on the episode but didn't give a number. |